By Daniel Borkert, FNP-C
Last reviewed October 30, 2026. Claims checked against the sources named below on October 29, 2026.
In my first year as a nurse practitioner, imposter syndrome felt like I did not belong there. It felt like I did not know what I was doing. I would feel fear, and a knotted anxious feeling in my stomach, that I was going to do something wrong.
Nothing about that year was unusual, and that is the point of this page. The feeling has a name, a research literature, and a shape that other clinicians have mapped. Most of what gets written about it offers either a percentage nobody can support or a pep talk nobody can use.
This page sets out what the feeling is and what the evidence says about how long the first year takes. It also examines the advice new clinicians hear most and what the research says builds confidence. The short version is that confidence does not arrive first and competence second. It runs the other way.
In this guide
- The short answer
- The feeling has a name, and a history
- How long does this last
- Fake it till you make it, examined
- What actually builds confidence
- Asking for help is part of the job
- One working day, ordered
- The honest summary
- Frequently asked questions
- Change log and corrections
- Sources for this page
The short answer
- The feeling is documented and named. Clance and Imes described the impostor phenomenon in 1978. The nurse practitioner literature frames it as a temporary, normal response to a role transition rather than a personal defect.
- No honest percentage exists. The general systematic review found reported rates scattered across most of the possible range, depending on the instrument and cutoff used. The nursing review found no nurse practitioner specific figure of any weight.
- Confidence is a byproduct. On the evidence, it follows repeated practice across a first year, time on a proficiency timeline measured in years, and support that is actually there. Asking and checking are part of the role, not evidence that you do not belong in it.
The feeling has a name, and a history
Clance and Imes built the original description from clinical work with more than 150 high achieving women. They included students, faculty, and professionals in fields including law, medicine, and nursing. Clance and Imes defined it as an internal experience of intellectual phoniness: a settled belief of not really being able despite degrees, honors, and praise.
They called it a phenomenon on purpose. It is not a syndrome in the medical sense or a disorder. It appears as a diagnosis in neither standard diagnostic manual. From the beginning, it was found in people succeeding by every external measure. The feeling is not a reading of your record. It never has been.
In a 2006 paper written for new NP graduates, the phenomenon is framed as a temporary and normal feeling that occurs at a role transition, rather than an abnormal one. The paper also names generalized anxiety, lack of self confidence, depression, and frustration at a self imposed standard. It is a narrative discussion, not a study, and reports no prevalence data of its own. That tells you how thin the NP specific literature on this feeling still is.
A 2022 scoping review searched six databases and included eleven studies. It found the phenomenon present in nursing students and nurses. The research was concentrated on prevalence and related factors, with very few studies addressing how to resolve the feelings.
A 2020 systematic review covered 62 studies and more than 14,000 participants. The rates reported in its studies ranged so widely, depending on the screening tool and cutoff chosen, that a single figure would misuse the review. The same review found the feelings common across sexes, ages, and professions, often alongside depression and anxiety. As of its search, no published study had evaluated any treatment. Anyone offering you a percentage, or a proven cure, is selling past the evidence.
The named conversation lives mostly outside nursing’s own books. Open the standard first year nursing books published over the last forty years and imposter syndrome is named in none of their contents. The feelings are there under older names: reality shock, role transition, the dream against the reality.
The named discussion sits in general psychology, where Clance’s book appeared in 1985, and in online communities. There, new graduates describe feeling dumb, feeling like a fraud, crying on lunch breaks and in cars. That is community testimony, not a finding. But it matches the sourced literature, and it is why this page will not promise an ending the evidence cannot date.
How long does this last
Ask in any community of new clinicians and one question comes back more than any other. How long until I feel confident, comfortable, like I know what I am doing, like a real provider. The community answers itself with numbers spanning six months to five years. That spread is honest in a way a single answer would not be.
Patricia Benner’s model of skill acquisition, built on the Dreyfus brothers’ work, describes five stages from novice to expert. The novice works from context free rules and cannot yet use discretionary judgment. The competent practitioner, typically at two to three years in the same job, begins to feel mastery. The timeline relayed in the NP paper runs three to five years from novice to proficient, more than five to expert.
A new NP in month three who feels like a beginner is, on the field’s own model, a beginner. That is accurate calibration rather than fraudulence. The model also explains the sharpest version of the feeling, the one the community names an identity crisis. Its stages attach to a domain, not to a person. An expert nurse who becomes a new provider re-enters at novice in the new domain, with a decade of expertise in the old one still intact.
A grounded theory model of the move into the NP role, From Limbo to Legitimacy, describes four phases: Laying the Foundation, Launching, Meeting the Challenge, and Broadening the Perspective. They run roughly from the first month through the end of the first year and beyond. The model comes from interviews with 35 graduates. It is qualitative theory rather than measurement, and its underlying study was set in primary care.
A second framework, Duchscher’s stages of new graduate transition, adds a detail worth expecting. Its first stage, dominated by what she calls transition shock, covers roughly the first three to four months. At approximately eight to nine months, the model predicts a second crisis, a dip after the first recovery, before the steadier stages arrive.
That prediction is relayed here through the later literature that summarises the model. It matches what the community describes anecdotally and almost never warns about. Feeling worse again at month eight is a described feature of this transition, not a relapse into fraudulence.
In a qualitative study of 23 first year NP graduates and 21 people who knew their practices, the new NPs described moving from overwhelmed to confident by the end of the first year. About a third of the NPs had changed employment within the period studied, naming conflict or problems with acceptance of their role. That finding is usually left out of the reassuring versions.
The study is small, qualitative, and set in one province’s primary health care system, and those limits travel with it. The arc from overwhelmed to steadier is real and documented. The year is not only an interior event. Sometimes the setting, not the clinician, is what has to change.
My own answer sits at the slower end of the community’s spread. It is worth giving, because nobody gave it to me. It took two to three years of consistent practice, closer to three to four, before it stopped feeling like acting and started feeling like real confidence. Through probably the first few years, the doubt did not fade on its own schedule either. It lingered until I had an answer, and then it would come back with the next question I could not answer yet.
So, how long does this last. The worst of it is front loaded into the first months, with a second dip worth expecting near the end of the first year. Proficiency in the literature takes three to five years. A new NP not feeling proficient at month ten is behind no schedule the evidence recognizes. Confidence is not the gate you pass before the real work starts. It is a residue the work leaves behind.
Fake it till you make it, examined
Every new clinician hears the phrase, usually in training, usually kindly. Fake it till you make it. Online, it is inherited advice from nursing school and a coping strategy for high pressure moments. A minority of creators reject it outright. What the comment threads almost never do is distinguish the two things the phrase can mean. The whole question lives in that distinction.
My own version of it was the first of those two things, though I could not have drawn the line at the time. In front of a patient, I could not appear super uncertain. Patients would not trust what I was telling them, and conversations would go quite poorly. So I expressed confidence while doubting inside. That is what the phrase meant in practice for me.
As my clinical judgment and ability grew, the confidence changed character. It became based on something real instead of performed over the uncertainty.
The turning point was not a technique. It was realizing I did not have to know all the answers all the time. It is okay to say I don’t know, I’ll look that up, I’ll get back to you, I’m not sure. Some questions have no certain answer at all. Saying so is not a failure of the performance. It is the end of needing one.
Two realizations carried that. In post acute care, where I started, I would usually have a follow up opportunity the next day or in the following days. So I did not have to solve everything at once, especially problems the patient was not there for.
And medicine is shared decision making. Patients do not necessarily want every problem solved, or solved my way, and most do not want extra medicines. I did not learn that nuance in a classroom. I learned it over time, from patients and from mentors.
The first meaning is composure: projecting steadiness so a patient and a team have something to organize around. The second meaning is concealment. A clinician who hides a gap from the colleague who could fill it or the senior who could check it has not performed competence. She has removed the gap from every process that could have caught it.
The phrase’s best known book length defender does not defend its plain meaning. Amy Cuddy’s Presence closes by retitling it, fake it till you become it. She rebuilds it as small nudges toward one’s own story rather than a performance of a false self. That is a cultural fact about the phrase, not evidence.
The psychology underneath explains why. In Bandura’s self efficacy theory, the strongest source of a person’s judgment about their own capability is mastery: their own performed successes. Performed confidence adds nothing there. It touches only the weaker channels: watching others, encouragement, and the state of the body.
Concealment is worse than neutral because it blocks the inputs that do work in a first year. Those include the mastery that comes from being checked and corrected, and the learning that comes from asking.
A new NP must act in the role before feeling like the role. The transition literature’s first phase is precisely that gap between the credential and the felt legitimacy. Acting in the role is not faking. It is the job, with the checking and asking left fully switched on.
The line the evidence supports is the same one. Act in the role, yes, at full stretch. Conceal a gap from the people and processes that exist to catch it, no.
The test is one question. Does anyone who could help you know what you do not know? If the answer is yes, you are not faking anything. You are practicing, at your stage, in the open.
What actually builds confidence
If confidence is a byproduct, it is worth being specific about what it is a byproduct of. Bandura’s four sources double as a practical list.
Mastery experiences first. Every case you work through, every decision you make and then verify, is a deposit in the one account that pays out in felt capability. This is why the community’s own best line on the subject, confidence does not come before experience, turns out to be the theory stated in plain words.
Vicarious experience second. When a task is novel and you have had few chances to perform it yourself, watching a clinician like you handle it, and encouragement, carry relatively more weight than they will later. Early on, other people’s steadiness is one of the main channels open to you, not a consolation prize.
Persuasion third, real but weak. That is why encouragement helps for an afternoon and mastery helps for a career. And the body’s state last. That is why a racing heart can talk you out of competence you demonstrably have.
My own first year followed this same sequence, though I would not have named it that way. Early on, the mentors and the references mainly helped me get through the day. I would check what I was doing against UpToDate and ask other providers what they would do in a certain situation. The day would get done.
As time went by, the order reversed. I was able to trust my judgment first, and then double check it against others, or against UpToDate and other resources. Same people, same tools, different relationship to them. The checking did not go away. It changed jobs, from carrying my decisions to auditing them. That change is most of what confidence felt like from the inside.
What I did not expect is that the worry eventually reverses. My concern now is the opposite of the first year’s. I worry that I am overconfident, that I do not know what I do not know, and that still scares me. I keep learning new things, and each one shows me there was probably a bunch I did not know while I was acting on the best knowledge I had.
The check I use now is the same sentence, grown up. I will need to look into it a little further. Saying it builds rapport rather than costing it, because I am not pretending to know an answer I do not have. It rarely needs saying, because common things occur commonly, and those I can usually address. The rest get looked into, out loud.
One small study belongs here, the nursing review’s only FNP specific dataset. In a 2002 survey of 32 family nurse practitioner students, impostor scores correlated negatively with confidence about succeeding in the future role. Thirty two students, self report, relayed through the review’s table, so its value is directional only. As confidence is fed by real practice, the feeling tends to quiet, the opposite of the sequence the faking advice assumes.
An integrative review of postgraduate NP residencies and fellowships, eleven studies in all, found increased confidence and preparedness as the major theme among participants. The review itself says the data on these programs’ efficacy is still scarce. That sentence travels with the finding wherever this page uses it. Where a first year is not deliberately structured, the new clinician has to build the same inputs by hand.
Asking for help is part of the job
Nothing in my first year mattered more than this, and it was not complicated. I had mentors who were always available to take my questions, even the very simple questions I might have, about how to round or how to do certain things.
Simple questions are the ones whose answers run your whole day. A mentor who takes them seriously is not being kind. She is being useful at the exact point of maximum leverage.
In a field study of 51 work teams, Edmondson studied a team’s shared belief that it is safe to take interpersonal risks, such as asking questions, seeking feedback, and discussing errors. That belief was associated with exactly that learning behavior, which in turn carried the team’s performance.
Two cautions belong with that study. Its setting was manufacturing teams, not clinical ones, and its findings are associations, not proof of cause. Psychological safety, the name for that shared belief, is a property of a team, not a trait a new graduate can be told to have.
Read with those cautions, the study still converts asking from a personality question into a structural one. A workplace that punishes questions is giving you information about itself, worth weighing when you choose where to work.
In the Ontario first year study, mentorship by a colleague had a positive effect on the transition. Lack of orientation and mentorship made it harder, and the authors recommend formal mentorship for every new graduate. That is a qualitative finding from one study, not a measured effect. Nothing in this page’s research quantifies how much mentorship helps. Consultation and support are part of the role, not an exception to it.
What asking looked like in the moment, for me, was a breath and a sentence. I’m not sure, I’ll have to look that up or get back to you. Or, I’ll have to talk to my attending physician. That was the whole move.
The other tool I had from the beginning was active listening. My mind might be panicking, but I would force myself to repeat what the patient was saying back in different words. It gave me a way to think through what they were actually saying and to reflect empathy for their situation, while the panic ran underneath. Between the listening and the sentence, I could stay in the room honestly until the answer arrived.
The fourth source of self judgment is the state of your own body. The fear I felt in my first year, and a knotted anxious feeling in my stomach, was not a report on my competence. It was one of the channels through which I was judging it, and channels can carry noise.
Knowing the alarm is a channel and not a verdict does not switch it off. It stops it from being the only evidence you hear, and the asking and checking continue either way.
One working day, ordered
A short account of the practical side, from my own first year, belongs here. It is the ground the feeling stood on.
Mornings began with a stack of overnight concerns, complaints, and questions from patients and families. At first the stack felt overwhelming, because everything in it seemed to want my attention at once.
What I had to learn was to filter. Which items needed to be addressed. Which needed only to be reviewed. Which could wait until a follow up visit in a few days. Ordering the day, deciding in sequence rather than reacting in arrival order, kept the volume from becoming the overwhelm.
The win I would name from that year is related. I learned to set a schedule and to set boundaries. I came in earlier and did paperwork while patients were still resting. There was a sweet spot for rounds, when patients were not occupied by other services. Paperwork went into the hours when they were busy with other things.
Nobody handed me that system. Here it is enough to say that the day getting ordered and the feeling getting quieter were not separate projects.
The honest summary
Here is what this page can and cannot honestly tell you. The feeling is named, documented, and about fifty years into being studied. The year has a shape, harder at the start and again, for many, near its end. Proficiency takes years, which makes a struggling tenth month a normal tenth month.
Confidence follows competence and support rather than preceding them. Asking and checking are how it gets built.
This page cannot tell you a percentage, because the literature cannot support one. It cannot promise the feeling retires, because the clinicians furthest from their first year say it does not, entirely. What changes is your relationship to it. It stops being a verdict and becomes weather, noticed and worked through. The community of new graduates has a four word version of the whole page. You are not behind.
Practice Brief signup. This page is part of a short series of practice guides for nurse practitioners beyond the boards. The Practice Brief is the email list that carries them.
Frequently asked questions
Is imposter syndrome a diagnosis?
No. Clance and Imes called it a phenomenon deliberately. It appears as a diagnosis in neither the DSM-5-TR nor the ICD-11. It is a described pattern of experience, first documented in high achieving women in 1978, not a disorder and not a billable condition.
How common is imposter syndrome among new nurse practitioners?
Nobody knows. The nursing scoping review found no NP specific prevalence figure of any weight. The general review found reported rates varying so widely by instrument and cutoff that a single percentage would misrepresent it. The evidence supports that the feeling is common, documented across professions, and a normal feature of role transitions.
Does the feeling go away?
The sourced arcs say it eases as competence grows. The first year study found its graduates describing confidence by the end of the year. Community testimony adds the second half: clinicians well past their first year report the doubt still visiting, particularly at transitions. Expect it to quiet and to change character, from a verdict on you to a signal you know how to read. Do not expect a date after which it never returns.
If I feel like an imposter, does that mean I am unsafe?
The feeling by itself is not a safety finding. It is documented in successful clinicians from the first description onward. The staging model says a beginner’s slowness and rule bound checking are the stage working as designed.
What deserves action is different in kind. A specific thing you do not know is a gap, and gaps have a procedure: look it up, ask, escalate, every time, without apology. A global feeling that you do not belong is weather, answered by the accumulation of checked, completed work. Confusing the two is where the risk actually sits.
Change log and corrections
This page carries a public change log. Every correction, addition, and re-verification is recorded here with its date and the source it was checked against.
| Date | Section | What changed | Checked against |
|---|---|---|---|
| October 30, 2026 | First publication | The page published with its statements drawn from the sources named below, each checked on October 29, 2026. | The sources named in the Sources section |
Corrections: to report a suspected error, email daniel@boardandbedside.com naming the section and the source you believe is current. A reported error is checked against its source before any change is made, and the outcome is recorded here either way.
Sources for this page
Clance PR and Imes SA. The imposter phenomenon in high achieving women, dynamics and therapeutic interventions. Psychotherapy, Theory, Research and Practice 1978;15(3):241-247. The origin and definition source, from clinical work with more than 150 high achieving women, verified in this research across scholarly renderings of the paper.
Clance PR. The Impostor Phenomenon, Overcoming the Fear That Haunts Your Success. Peachtree Publishers, 1985. The author’s own book length statement of the construct, the primary book source for the definition.
Huffstutler S and Varnell G. The Impostor Phenomenon in New Nurse Practitioner Graduates. Topics in Advanced Practice Nursing 2006;6(2). The NP specific source, a narrative discussion paper, for the role transition framing, the feelings named with it, and the timeline it relays from Benner. It reports no prevalence data.
Peng Y et al. The Impostor Phenomenon Among Nursing Students and Nurses, A Scoping Review. Frontiers in Psychology 2022;13:809031. Six databases, eleven studies, for the phenomenon in nursing, the research’s concentration on prevalence, the scarcity of work on resolution, and the Vance 2002 dataset in its Table 1, used here in relayed form.
Bravata DM et al. Prevalence, Predictors, and Treatment of Impostor Syndrome, A Systematic Review. Journal of General Internal Medicine 2020;35(4):1252-1275. Sixty two studies, for the prevalence range finding and why no single figure is printed here, and the absence of any evaluated treatment as of the review.
Brown MA and Olshansky EF. From Limbo to Legitimacy, A Theoretical Model of the Transition to the Primary Care Nurse Practitioner Role. Nursing Research 1997;46(1):46-51. The four phase model, read here in Huffstutler and Varnell 2006 and Sullivan-Bentz et al 2010, its sample read in a concept analysis. Qualitative theory; its study was set in primary care.
Sullivan-Bentz M et al. Supporting Primary Health Care Nurse Practitioners’ Transition to Practice. Canadian Family Physician 2010;56(11):1176-1182. A qualitative study of 23 first year NP graduates and 21 coparticipants, for the overwhelmed to confident arc, the one third who changed employment, and the formal mentorship recommendation. Single province, primary health care setting.
McDonough KE. Outcomes of Postgraduate Fellowships and Residencies for Nurse Practitioners, An Integrative Review. Journal of Professional Nursing 2024;53:95-103. Eleven studies, for confidence and preparedness as the major theme, carried here only with the review’s statement that efficacy data remains scarce.
Duchscher JEB. Transition Shock, The Initial Stage of Role Adaptation for Newly Graduated Registered Nurses. Journal of Advanced Nursing 2009;65(5):1103-1113. For transition shock as the named first stage of entering practice. The companion stages model, with the predicted crisis at eight to nine months, is Duchscher 2008 as rendered in later literature, used here in relayed form.
Bandura A. Self-efficacy theory, as stated in Artino AR Jr, Academic Self-Efficacy, Perspectives on Medical Education 2012, and Gale J et al 2021, used here in relayed form through those two agreeing sources; Bandura’s own texts were not opened in this research. Skill staging is Benner P, From Novice to Expert, American Journal of Nursing 1982, and the book of the same name, Addison-Wesley 1984.
Edmondson A. Psychological Safety and Learning Behavior in Work Teams. Administrative Science Quarterly 1999;44(2):350-383. A field study of 51 manufacturing work teams, for the association between a team’s shared belief that interpersonal risk is safe and learning behavior. Correlational and team level, used with those cautions.
Cuddy A. Presence, Bringing Your Boldest Self to Your Biggest Challenges. Little, Brown and Company, 2015. A cultural source only, for fake it till you make it and its closing chapter’s revision of it. Not an evidence source.
Community listening, October 2026. First person accounts by new nurses and nurse practitioners in public online communities and creator content on Reddit, YouTube, Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok, used only as testimony, attributed as such where it appears. Private groups were not read. Figures circulating in community posts were not verified and are not used.
Every statement on this page is drawn from the sources in this list, each checked on the date shown, and the sourcing is rechecked at every refresh.
For clinician education only — not medical advice.

Leave a Reply